Tires for a Big Expedition Truck: Goodyear vs Michelin vs Pirelli vs Continental
Tires are one of the most debated topics in the expedition truck world. There are not many manufacturers of big tires, and people are very set in their ways. The main options are Goodyear, Michelin, Pirelli and Continental. There are a few Chinese manufacturers too, which, honestly, I would not consider.
Goodyear MV/T
Goodyear has one of the highest speed ratings in this size, so if your truck will live mostly on the highway, it is a decent choice. The tread is quiet on the road. It is also the most readily available tire, which makes it the cheapest, and it has the biggest resale market, so you can find one at a pretty decent price.
The problem is the sidewall. It is the weakest of any of them, so if you air down for off-road, it is very easy to puncture. I have punctured three, and none of them should have punctured. That is how weak this tire is.
Michelin XZL, XML and XZL2
The original LMTVs came on Michelin XMLs, a beefy off-road tire. They got a bad reputation because so many were dry-rotted by the time people bought their trucks secondhand, and they popped. On a new set, honestly, I have heard nothing but good things. It is a very off-road-ready tire.
The XZL is less off-road focused, with the same sidewall, a bit deeper tread and better on-road manners. It is a fantastic tire.
The XZL2 keeps all of that but gives you less tread depth. The military wanted a cheaper tire and was not using the trucks enough to need the deep tread of the original. If you can find the original deep-tread version, it would 100% be my first choice.
Pirelli PS22
Pirelli is what I run now. It carries the same load rating as the Michelin XZL, and I find it a little better on the road. I think it is a better-looking tire, too, and it does much better at highway speed than the Michelins a friend runs on his Unimog.
I have about 10,000 miles on my Pirellis and somewhere around 75% to 80% of the tread left.
Continental
Continental is very expensive and very hard to find in the United States. Continental does not sell these here, so it is resellers bringing them over from Europe. The people I know who run them say it is an amazing tire. It just does not last. I usually hear somewhere between 20,000 and 30,000 miles, which is almost nothing for a tire like this.
The specs, side by side
I pulled the published specs for the 395/85R20 size, the common LMTV fitment, from the manufacturers and big-tire dealers. Some numbers simply are not published, so I have marked those.
Goodyear MV/T
- Load index: 161 (14-ply) or 168 (20-ply)
- Speed rating: K, 68 mph (110 km/h)
- Tread depth: 26/32 in (21 mm)
- Overall diameter: 46.6 in
- Weight: 206 to 216 lb
Michelin XZL
- Load index and speed: 168G, 56 mph (90 km/h). Michelin's US spec sheet lists 70 mph for the load range G version.
- Tread depth: 33/32 in (26 mm)
- Overall diameter: 46.8 in
- Weight: not published
Michelin XZL2 (X Force 2)
- Load index and speed: 168K, 68 mph (110 km/h)
- Tread depth: not published, but shallower than the XZL
Pirelli PS22
- Load index and speed: 168G, 56 mph (90 km/h), or 161J, 62 mph (100 km/h)
- Overall diameter: 46.6 in (1,183 mm)
- Tread depth and weight: not published
Continental HCS
- Load index and speed: 168J or 166K
- Michelin XZL33/32 in
- Goodyear MV/T26/32 in
On paper, the Goodyear's speed rating is matched by the XZL2 and the Continental, and the Pirelli and XZL carry the same 168 load index. What the spec sheets do not tell you is how strong the sidewall feels at low pressure on rocks. That only comes from miles.
Why I stress tires so much
I have popped so many tires driving on older Goodyears and older Michelins. I have been stranded in northern British Columbia and in Flagstaff, Arizona, both because of tire problems. That is why I would never buy another Goodyear.
These are not vehicles you want to cheap out on tires with and get stranded somewhere remote.
Check the date code before anything else. On my first day with my first truck, I blew the driver's front tire at highway speed. It was 20 years old. Rubber that old is brittle, no matter how much tread it has left.
Questions people ask
What size tires does an LMTV use?
The common LMTV fitment is 395/85R20, about 46.6 to 46.8 inches tall depending on the brand.
Are Goodyear MV/T tires good for an expedition truck?
They are quiet and cheap, but in my experience the sidewall is the weakest of the big options. I punctured three while aired down off-road.
How long do Pirelli PS22 tires last?
I have about 10,000 miles on mine with roughly 75% to 80% of the tread left.
For everything else I would fix on a new truck, read so you bought an LMTV.
Read nextExpedition Truck Power Systems: Solar, Batteries and What I'd Change6 min readThe short version goes up on Instagram and TikTok first. A new post lands here on Fridays.
